In Aza’s recent blog, he was looking for examples of good, and bad, user interfaces.
Here is the bath/shower tap that I found in my hotel here in Tokyo yesterday morning. After quite some trial-and-error, I’ve figured out that with this one tap, you can:
- or bath
- or both
- while adjusting temperature for each *independently*!!
- and with a safety red button (visible on top left) which you have to press before you can raise shower temperature above 40C to avoid accidental scalding. Note the lack of scald control on the bath tap, as its not needed.
- and with a separate water on/off lever (visible on top right), once you get the shower water temperature just right, you can leave the temperature knobs set, and the shower temperature will automatically be perfect tomorrow morning! 🙂
While it does do all of these things quite well, and I do now like it, it was more of an IQ test then I needed in a pre-caffeinated, jet lagged state, first thing yesterday morning.
Putting hot/cold taps by the shower head, and another set of hot/cold taps by the bath spout is (probably) more complex to install, but would have been more intuitive to use, imho. Also, as a nit: while the red “scald-prevention” safety button makes sense, the other two red dots are only for alignment; using the same color red for those confused me into thinking they were also for safety / hot water. Took some experiments to backtrack and figure out one was shower, one was bath, and the extra red dots were decoys. And yes, I got quite wet in the process! 🙂
UPDATE: I just discovered that part of the tap pivots!?!?! Part of it sticks out so far that I bumped into it while showering. At first I was worried that I broke it, but after some playing discovered its hinged and is designed to swing fully back to the wall in either direction. Thats good, because it makes standing in the shower much easier now. Of course, I’ve no idea why the water-into-bath tap had to protrude that far in the first place; somehow a shorter, non-pivoting, taphead seems like it would have been easier. John 12mar2009
5 thoughts on “User interface stories from a Tokyo hotel”
Thermostat-driven shower taps are quite popular (and affordable) in Europe in the mean time. We have the same thing in our house — minus the bath part. And I agree, both the “safety button” and the fact that it “remembers” the right temperature between uses is excellent.
“and with a separate water on/off lever (visible on top right), once you get the shower water temperature just right, you can leave the temperature knobs set, and the shower temperature will automatically be perfect tomorrow morning!”
There are two broad families of shower controls – pressure value and thermostatic. Thermostatic controls remember the temperature setting and can do unusual things but they are way more expensive.
Check out Kohler DTV, popular with the Grammy winner crowd.
It is a computer controlled thermostatic shower value with up to twelve independent water outlets that pulse in time to music. I wonder if it runs Linux.
Fantastic post, John. This is feature creep in physical form.
I think the word ‘overcomplicated’ comes to mind here. My shower/bath consists of a rotating lever – turn left/right for temperature, up/down for pressure – and a switch to divert water between shower head and bath tap. A monkey could handle it, so even a jet-lagged caffeine-deprived traveler could probably work it out. 🙂
This is anxiety provoking.
I’m glad my shower only featured one twisty knob.
You must log in to post a comment.